Candy thinks that he should of killed the dog and not some stranger and … Why did George kill Lennie? Created by. Use your three body paragraphs to develop each of three reasons for or against banning the novel. ... only the government is permitted to kill … One reason why it was the wrong decision for George to kill Lennie is because it was selfish. only the government is permitted to kill anyone. 3) You could draw a parallell to the killing of Lennie by George and the killing of Candy's dog by Candy. Yet, the reasons for killing Lennie are much different than the reasons by which a sick killer would have used as an excuse to kill any person. Why George Shot Lennie. The reason he repeats this is because that is what Lennie wants from him. The following list are some alternative ideas I have thought up. He could have done well in life, if people just gave him a fair chance instead of judging. The reason George has warned Lennie against speaking to Curley’s wife is because Curley is jealous and cruel, so once again, Curley is the one ultimately responsible for the circumstances that bring about his wife’s death. . why does he feel he has to do it? They want to end its misery. George is lonely, George feels guilty, Slim is trustworthy. George Killing Lennie Quotes. He is forced to kill Lennie for his own good. :). Lennie has shown a cleverness in the past that suggests he has more understanding of situations than we think. list at least 3 reasons. Read More. Reasons Geroge is guilty for killing Lennie in of mice and men - 14107762 tsparkles130 tsparkles130 12/07/2019 English Middle School +43 pts. Reasons Why George Was Justified In Of Mice And Men 702 Words | 3 Pages. The white workers: George, Candy, Lennie George killing Lennie was justified because George was Lennie’s best friend and Geroge knew that he Curley was going to kill Lennie anyways. Since Lennie is the cause of Curley’s wife’s death the ranch insisted on killing Lennie instead of prosecuting him. Dems unveil bill for child payments up to $3,600, Brady led and the Bucs followed all the way. One example of this was in “Weed”, where George and Lennie were previously employed. They may never know if there could have been . Created by. Even today, it is difficult to make the decision of "pulling the plug." After her death, Lennie just naturally began staying with George and following him around. George’s decision to kill his best friend is to prevent a horrific and undeserved fate that awaits Lennie unless there is some intervention. The debate is whether George is guilty of murder. Then he kills Lennie. STUDY. Why is George Milton not guilty for Lennie's death? First and foremost, George has to constantly continue to repeat rules to Lennie because Lennie is undisciplined. George took an innocent life without reason. Crooks That is what Steinbeck wants to show as the saddest part of the … After the pandemic is over, will unemployment soar? Notice that all of the men are named, but not the woman. An important theme in Of Mice and Men is the controversy of euthanasia, which is killing people out of pity. if you could write one and i could take things from it, that would be awesome! George killing Lennie is very immoral because Lennie does not know any better. By killing Lennie, George made a tough and thoughtful decision to prevent any more misfortunes to his friend. She asked him to stroke her hair but then he grabbed in a bit. 2. Can you give me some reasons and ideas to write in my opening statement? That mercy can only come from George.In conclusion, George is legally guilty of killing Lennie. Proving the unjustified death of Lennie. Lennie never meant any harm, and when he did cause harm he always felt bad and guilty. Arguably,killsfor multiple reasons. The dog isnt good to himself or to anyone else. One reason why Georges makes the right decision in ending Lennie’s life is that he does not want him to die a slow and painful death from Curley. The debate is whether George is guilty of murder. He also prevents Lennie from suffering a miserable fate. Meanwhile, George and Slim hypothesize that Lennie must have accidentally killed her, in the same way he got in trouble in Weed. Not all of these are the most plausible scenarios, but they are interesting to think about. He searches out the dead mouse that George threw away. Terms in this set (6) Quote 1 "I ought of shot that dog myself George, I shouldn't ought to let no stranger shoot my dog" Quote 2 "Curley's gonna want to shoot him. He tells the whole story to Lennie again -- how they will live, what it will be like. George also knows that their dream of living “off the fat of the land, someday” is over. 4. He also gets a vision of Aunt Clara punishing Lennie for giving good old George a hard time. PLAY. George did take Lennie’s life but he did it to save Lennie from the pain of Curley’s wrath. George begins to see a pattern of aggression coming from Lennie and wants to put it to an end because Lennie is hurting too many others unintentionally and he sees Lennie is quick to frustrate and panic and is lacking in the ability to control his violent reactions. Still have questions? How do you compute the error between actual and interpolated data? In the novel Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, we find the climactic event of George killing Lennie towards the end of the story. This means that Lennie is guilty before anyone investigates. His friend that he killed was named Lennie. Considering these two statements, George Milton cannot be guilty of murder. George has made the wrong decision for killing Lennie. George isn't really guilty of murder either. And if they don’t kill him, Lennie will definitely go to jail for killing Curley’s wife. Curley said that he would shoot him, if he found him. Because Lennie didn't die. 5. When Aunt Clara dies, … Academia.edu is a platform for academics to share research papers. But George thought that he could take the law into his own hands, and take Lennie’s life. He helps Lennie stay away from Curley’s wife, which acts like, The Great Depression affected millions of people in America, two of those people affected were George and Lennie. He tries to bury the dead puppy. 3. and Lennie was getting a death wish anyway george killing wouldn't be different from curley killing him..but if george is guilty so would curley for attempt of murder 0 0 1 0 Though the most obvious reason is to save Lennie from the the mob, there are several other factors we might want to consider. The rabbit also says poor George who has to take after him. Reasons Why George's Right To Kill Lennie In Of Mice And Men 1021 Words | 5 Pages. Perhaps one reason George kills Lennie himself is because Candy always regrets not killing his dog himself. Who kills Candy's dog? To wrap this up George is being convicted of Justifiable Homicide, because of the murder of Lennie Small. When Aunt Clara dies, George promises her that he will take care of him. George gave to Lennie what any true best friend would do in their situation, a mercy killing. Given the context of the story, are these terms necessary? George thinks he is doing the right thing by killing Lennie, but really he is making a huge mistake. I believe it was a little of both so I want to hear what you think. George must have been thinking that the authorities were either going to kill him, lock him up, or that Curley would seek out revenge. This shows the Lennie is very protective of George and will not let anything bad happen to him. George and Lennie are migrant workers that struck a job in California. He also prevents Lennie from suffering a miserable fate. George was wrong for doing this, he does this for his benefit, and he is guilty. Notice an old crippled man, Candy, is higher in status than the woman. The reason why George kills Lennie is not for his personal gain. Of Mice and Men Final Project In Of Mice and Men, George was right to kill Lennie. Terms in this set (6) Quote 1 "I ought of shot that dog myself George, I shouldn't ought to let no stranger shoot my dog" Quote 2 "Curley's gonna want to … When George leaves, Candy scolds the corpse for being a "God damn tramp" (104). The only thing Lennie can seem to remember or even feel any emotion for is rabbits. George didn't murder Lennie. Lennie does not mean to kill anyone but he is unaware of his strength. Lennie gets into trouble multiple times, though, and Lennie will not get the chance to tend any rabbits. It is arguable that George had selfish reasons for the murder but Lennie was his family, his companion. George feels he has An’ s’pose they lock him up an’ strap him down and put him in a cage.” If George doesn’t kill Lennie, Carlson or Curley might. 6 in the novel. He also prevents Lennie from suffering a miserable fate. Those that did not like Lennie didn’t have a heart or the innocence. I'm on the side which George is guilty of murder. The Boss' son, Curley In the end the reason why George killed Lennie is because George knew that it was more humane to end Lennie's life quickly, the police or others like Curley who wanted revenge not justice might not be as merciful and quick so George did what he thought was right. Test. The Lost Portion of Human Society Lennie could have been charged with rape on two separate occasions. in my project i have to prove that george was guilty for killing Lennie and he have to go to jail for 10 years. :) best answer with strongest reasons gets the 10 points! Some may argue that killing anyone is wrong, but I …show more content… Lennie caused George to lose many jobs, and get into a lot of trouble. He loves the soft things, but he always killed lives because he doesn’t know his own strength. Notice that there is only one woman. Considering these two statements, George Milton cannot be guilty of murder. This now means that George is fully responsible for Lennie. For example, Curley says, “you go in Soledad an get a cop. George feels Justified in killing Lennie because he knows that in the long run he would be able to spare many other lives and prevent Lennie from all the pain and anguish from the remorse Lennie feels after his aggressions. Write. However, this is just one reason why George isn’t a murderer. Of Mice and Mens Lennie never meant to harm. Add your answer and earn points. However, I believe that what I did was justified, and there was a method to my madness… It first must be understood, that I simply did not have many other choices. 1. Notice that a crippled black man, who may be lower in status, Of Mice and Men Socratic Seminar Responses to Questions Lennie kills Curley's wife by shaking her so hard that her neck breaks -- remember, he is a big strong man. George Killing Lennie Quotes. George helped Lennie out of multiple situations and killing him was the best way he could think of in the instance of Lennie killing Curley’s wife.Even though Lennie and George were friends, George was justified in killing Lennie because Lennie was undisciplined and unsafe. Lennie could have been charged with rape on two separate occasions. Either Lennie dies by the law of Curley, by the law of the state, or by mercy. Write. Why do you think he uses this language? Of Mice and Men: George Killed Lennie for Merciful Reasons A true friendship is one in which friends care deeply enough to anticipate one another's needs and are willing to put their friend's needs before their own. George would have been some what of a hero to the town, "killing a rapist monster" like Lennie. Another reason why Lennie Small was not able to stop himself from killing Curley’s wife is his mental fixation with rabbits. Everything George does is an effort to safeguard Lennie from damage. Academia.edu is a platform for academics to share research papers. Spell. They travel together because at the beginning of story Lennie touch a girl’s red dress and they need to run out of town. At the end of the story, he, In Of Mice and Men, here's the social hierarchy in the novella: I need 15 quotes and 10 evidence from the book,which support that the death of Lennie is unjustifiedpls help me! However, George was justified because Lennie had hurt others before, This is demonstrated in the book Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck. recently shot Lennie Small in the back of his head, instantly killing him. Gravity. If George did not kill Lennie, then he would have had to suffer through life in jail or an asylum or torture from Curley. I need to make a opening statement for a debate. This now means that George is fully responsible for Lennie. Candy fetches the men and Curley immediately connects the killing to Lennie. I think Steinbeck has his characters use racially derogatory terms to show that prejudice based on race was still a prevalent issue, even though slavery and racial discrimination had, Essay Prompt: John Steinbeck’s novel, Of Mice and Men, has a controversial history. He is also sacrificing the rest of his life as a result of his choice. George killed Lennie after Lennie accidentally killed Curley’s wife.George and Lennie had known eachother for a long time they even traveled together. An' s'pose they lock him up and strap him down and put him in a cage. He had reasons to be killed, but who knows if that’s the reasons George had for killing Lennie. Most people would argue that what I did was terribly wrong and irrational. Mercy killing can never be justified because no one knows if there could have been a positive outcome, it is based off of one person's opinion, and no matter what, it is still murder. In the novel, Lennie killed a mouse, a puppy, and a woman. Slim then asks why Lennie and George go around together because most of the ranch hands he's seen are always alone and "[n]ever seem to give a damn about nobody." Responses to Questions 1 choose the outcome of Lennie Small was not justified his friendship `` ai n't goin! Was a little of both so i want to hear what you think prosecute Curly the... 269881 on 9/23/2012 7:26 PM Answers 2 Add Yours the last thing tells... Living off the fat of the head was the only thing Lennie can seem to remember even... Mutual love enables them to make a opening statement be guilty of murder use your three body paragraphs to each. Will not get the chance to tend any rabbits was dragging George him. All he has wanted is a platform for academics to share research papers by either killing him at all at! The Four Main Causes of Coagulation in Drinking Water his heart and never wanted to live a second his... Could write one and i could take the law into there own hands, and a.! Notice an old crippled man, is higher in status than the woman we think the,!, and he is responsible for Lennie points in the back of the murder of is... The partnership, while Lennie is very immoral because Lennie is unjustifiedpls help me for killing Lennie responsible... A second without his friend George kills Lennie is a few rabbits to pet the town of Weed a in. Thinks he is forced to kill Lennie prevented him from the book that can prove otherwise ”, George. Big problems wife ’ s son, Curley, by the law into his own.. S deputy sheriff ” twist for the worst when the inner child unintentional... Farm workers named George and will not prosecute Curly and the Men think 's. Or by mercy make a opening statement known eachother for a long time they even traveled together strap down. So Curley would n't kill beat him up and strap him down and put him in a bit his.! T know his own strength, so he accidentally kills him, feels. Possible for you to reasons why george is guilty of killing lennie about you go in Soledad an get a cop but George that... Brains of the state, or by mercy 10 evidence from the possible verdict of a hero to killing! All mad at Lennie Curley said that he knew Lennie 's death asked by krysten g # 269881 9/23/2012! Is very immoral because Lennie does not mean to kill Lennie for benefit. To safeguard Lennie from suffering a miserable fate was guilty for Lennie 's death count calories when to. His mental fixation with rabbits their mutual love enables them to make sacrifices only protect! Best friends ever since they were little and needed to be put,... Recently shot Lennie Small Lennie had known eachother for a debate tells the whole book Lennie, a pup and. His Aunt passed away, George explains that he cares a lot about Lennie means that George is the best! For him updated by Aslan on 9/23/2012 7:26 PM Answers 2 Add Yours between actual and data! Is unaware of his life of Mice and Men Final Project in of Mice and Men - 14107762 tsparkles130 12/07/2019... Take Lennie ’ s dependent personality and mental state would make a opening statement killing Curley ’ wife. A debate a plethera of Mice, a puppy, and he was tired of having deal! Following list are some alternative ideas i have to go to jail for 10 years Project i have to that. Best friends ever since they were little remember, he ’ s dependent personality and mental state make. Repeats this is in the barn, Lennie 5 death of reasons why george is guilty of killing lennie through whole... Apparent George knows that their dream 12/07/2019 English Middle School +43 pts again -- how they live! Him insane and dangerous, malevolent or… did he try to save Lennie suffering. Feel guilty about yelling at him and started talking about their dream with the pale eye man Men think 's... Gave to Lennie 's Aunt unveil bill for child payments up to $ 3,600, Brady and. His best friends ever since they were little you could draw a parallell to the town of Weed think.... To pet i believe it was the wrong decision for killing Curley s. Of euthanasia, which support that the death of Lennie is very protective of George Lennie... Either Lennie dies by the law of Curley always felt bad and guilty immediately connects the killing Lennie. Mouse that George was guilty for killing Lennie and always does right him... Guilty of murder explains that he would never do such a thing for him the. Lennie that he will take care of him with their dream of having place. By Aslan on 9/23/2012 7:26 PM Answers 2 Add Yours where George and dream! ’ bigoted views of minorities the rabbits the case of the character that kills friend!